Payroll Sales Rep Activity, Quotas, and Commissions
Guidance on payroll activity, quotas, commissions from beta to GA.
Payroll Sales Rep Activity, Quotas, and Commissions
Goal: this document will outline the expectations a Check Partner should have of their payroll sales team from Beta to 6 - 12 months of GA. The reason for this timeframe is this is when your sales team are trained, have had a couple of initial conversations with payroll prospects, and before there is enough historical references for your team to forecast activity expectations.
Output: Sales Performance and Compensation Plan - This document will serve as a guideline for sales reps to understand their performance metrics, quota expectations, and potential earnings through commissions, fostering a motivated sales force aligned with company goals during the critical early stages of the payroll product's go-to-market strategy.
Activity
We are going to discuss this into 3 types of sales motions Check Partners find fit into their current GTM workstreams, then cover the baseline activity all sale motions go through, and finally review what, if any, adjustment considerations for each type of sales motion.
3 Sales Motions
All Products Inbound - These sales reps products all directly compliment each other and are easily cross-sold. Their activity consists of presenting on first-meetings / demos that are set for them through marketing and product-led initiatives.
All Products Inbound sales leads are mostly either window shopping or have nearly made their decision to move forward based on the marketing content and need to check a few last boxes. The sales rep needs to be able to quickly context switch between these two personas and effectively follow up with all first-meetings that don’t close they host.
Multi-Product Account Management - A sales motion a number of Check Partners have selected to use to sell payroll is including payroll as another product their Account Managers upsell their customer base with.
These Account Managers often have a working relationship with their book of customers and can easily schedule first meetings with their base. However, Check finds these sales representatives take longer to ramp as payroll has a high level of edge cases a sales rep must be able to discuss and knowing all of those edge cases on top of their other products can be challenging.
Payroll Only Current Customer Upsell - Check Partners that do have a suite of different products their platform offers find a blend of All Products Inbound and Multi-Product Account Management is the most effective model; or the hub-and-spoke model.
This model is built with 1 - 2 sales representatives sharing a round-robin style first-meeting booking system as well as partnering with their core product Sales teammates and Marketing on the outbound content to the customer base.
Baseline Activity Expectations
Understanding the baseline expectations of a payroll sales representative's daily activity is vital for aligning performance goals and optimizing time management. It ensures consistent, high-quality customer interactions while enabling effective performance assessment and targeted improvement efforts.
- Preparation Research: Spend 5 - 10 minutes for each scheduled meeting a sales rep has for the week to research the prospect so they can be prepared to speak directly to assumed pain points for prospect personas of customers that are window shoppers as well as be prepared to respond to customers who are mostly sold but need a couple of quick “can-it-do” questions.
- First Meeting / Demo: Each of these meetings should take 30 minutes and be focused on direct pain point extraction questions, quickly covering “can-it-do”, and showcasing how your payroll platform will positively impact the payroll prospect’s business.
- NOTE: It is necessary for your payroll sales representatives to assume the sale and end these meetings by asking if they have any objections to moving to your payroll platform and to schedule their implementation call.
- Follow Up: If the prospect has questions the sales representative was not able to address on the First Meeting/Demo, they will need to have fast and effective follow up with the payroll prospect. An effective sales representative should plan on needing to follow up with a prospect 3 times before the second meeting is locked in, with each time being a 5 minute activity. Therefore, a sales rep should expect to spend 15 minutes per week on follow up for each first-meeting they host.
- NOTE: Extracting the follow up time requirements, you can quickly calculate how impactful having a strong First Meeting/Demo is to maximizing your sales velocity.
Activity Considerations for each Sales Motion
Adapting sales activity expectations based on different sales motions is essential because each motion, whether All Products, Multi-Product AM, or Payroll Only, requires distinct approaches and time investments. Tailoring expectations ensures sales teams focus on the appropriate activities that resonate with the specific motion, leading to more relevant customer engagements and higher chances of successful conversions.
All Products Inbound | Multi-Product AM | Payroll Only | |
Preparation Research | Higher volume, needs to be able to quickly tie payroll into different customer personas. | Knows customers more intimately and should be able to tailor value to individual business cases. | Receives opp handoff info from other products teams and/or review customer databases. |
First Meeting / Demo | Target 6 - 8 meetings per week | Target 3 - 4 meetings per week | Target 6 - 8 meetings per week |
Follow Up | Must respond quickly and enter into an automated campaign to book implementation call. | Will have more follow up action items due to not being able to deep dive on payroll education. Should plan on having a follow up meeting after each demo. | If rep receives a lead from another product team, keep all parties updated on progress. |
Quota
Creating a sales quota for a new product requires a balance between setting ambitious goals and being realistic about the challenges of launching something new. Regular assessment and adaptation are key to ensuring the quotas remain aligned with the evolving market landscape.
For the timeframe this document covers, Beta to first 12 months of GA, Check recommends sales goals instead of quotas to hold sales representatives accountable to. An important note is that the majority of Check’s Partners find the legacy payroll sale funnel still applies to their sales motion, even when selling to current customers. This sales funnel is a 10 - 33 - 90 rule; 10% of your outreach will book a demo/first meeting, 33% of those prospects will say yes after 1 - 3 meetings, and 90% of that demographic will process their first payroll within 45 days of starting their implementation.
Therefore, work with your finance and sales leadership teams to create your sales goals and work backwards to create your sales goals.
Commissions
In the dynamic realm of sales, a finely tuned payroll sales representative commission structure stands as the nexus between fiscal prudence and unbridled motivation. Striking the delicate balance between minimizing costs of commissions and igniting sales representatives' fervor is not just a challenge; it's a strategic imperative. This section will cover sales commission payout amounts, thresholds for amplified payouts, clawbacks, and true-ups.
It is Check’s recommendation to launch your payroll product with a single commission payout percentage of first year’s estimated revenue. After 12 months of operating in GA you may consider adding features to your commission payouts.
NOTE: There are unique California rules for commission based pay. Prior to determining the rules regarding the use of commissions as a form of compensation in the state of California, it is important to understand how the state of California defines commissions. Please request more information from Check if you have sales representatives based in California.
Payouts
The critical considerations for how to payout the sales commissions are:
- Commissions are only paid out on the last payroll run of the month after the first payroll run month.
- Example: Acme Inc. processes their first payroll on February 6th and the payroll provider is on bi-weekly payroll so the sales rep will be paid their commissions on the last payroll run of March.
- Revenue amounts are calculated by multiplying the revenue of the first month of the first payroll run by 12.
- Acme Inc. ran in February with 10 employees at $10 monthly fee + $5 PEPM. The sales representative will be paid out on $720 of ARR.
- Future additional product upsell opportunities are calculated based only on PEPM.
- In April Acme Inc. adds ATS at $1.50 PEPM and the sales representative is paid out on $180 of ARR.
- Legacy payroll providers start their commission payouts between 9% - 11% of ARR.
Considering the structure of other products a payroll company is selling when adjusting their commission payouts is crucial to ensure equitable compensation. This approach prevents disproportionate incentives that could lead to neglecting certain offerings, promoting a balanced focus on the entire product portfolio and maximizing overall business growth.
All Products Inbound | Multi-Product AM | Payroll Only | |
Commission | Consider adding multipliers to selling full product suite opportunities. | Payroll can be a longer and more technical sales cycle. Ensure the payout for the time and effort put into payroll is competitive. | Check recommends a 80/20 commission split between payroll only and other product sales reps. |
Appendix
Please consult with Check before applying any of the commission adjustments.
Commission Amplifiers
Commission amplifiers are used to motivate sales representatives to push more products per sales opportunity as well as rewarding top performers. There are three primary forms amplifiers take:
- Unit Sales - SMB payroll sales opportunities take the same amount of administrative time from a sales representative of gathering the required information to hand off to implementation. In order to ensure sales representatives are treating all SMB sales opportunities equally a payroll provider will give a higher percentage of commission payout on ARR based on the volume of unit sales.
- Product Cross-selling - A fully built out Payroll/HR product stack includes ATS, New Hire Onboarding, HRIS, Benefit Admin, Timekeeping, Learning Management System, and many more platforms. These products have their own ARR associated with adding them to a sales opportunity but to motivate sales representatives to push more products a payroll provider can add higher percentage of commission payout based on the number of products that are cross-sold per sales opportunity.
- Revenue Targets - The most common commission amplifier is providing revenue milestones for your payroll sales representatives to hit that will elevate them into a higher percentage of commission payout. It is critical that you understand your payroll economics to properly map out revenue target amplifiers because misallocated buckets can cause your greatest sales representatives to become a liability instead of an asset.
Commission Clawbacks
A commission clawback is when a previously paid out sales opportunity ends their service agreement with a payroll provider within a defined clawback period. The reasoning of why payroll providers add clawback windows is to ensure the sales representatives are effectively selling their opportunities and/or keep their clients engaged so that if issues arise they can help address them before churn. Common clawback clauses are often reflected in the size of the sales opportunities with SMB requiring 30 - 60 day windows and mid-market and above requiring 90 days.
An example is if a sales representative was paid $100 in commissions in March for a deal that ran February 1st and has a 60 day clawback window policy. The employer ends their service with March 27th and so that sales representative will have $100 deducted (or clawed back) from their April commission check.
Commission True-ups
A sales "true-up" refers to a process in which a company reconciles or adjusts sales commissions or incentives that were initially estimated or paid based on provisional data. This often occurs when sales data or metrics are subject to changes, corrections, or updates after the initial commission payments have been made. The true-up process involves comparing the initial commission calculations with the updated or accurate sales figures, and then making necessary adjustments to ensure that sales representatives receive the appropriate amount of compensation based on their actual performance.
Employee count on seasonal businesses can fluctuate wildly and incentivizes sales representatives to submit higher employee count businesses during their peaks instead of when it is most advantageous to onboard the employer. This is why payroll providers will offer their sales representatives the opportunity to “true-up” an opportunity within a defined window and minimum threshold so that the sales representative still submits the opportunity when it is best for the employer and implementation teams.
There are three considerations when a sales representative submits for a true-up:
- Timeline - The main driver for offering true-ups is to adjust for seasonal employers and therefore most payroll providers limit the timeline a sales opportunity is eligible for a true-up to 6 months.
- Employee Growth - True-ups take time out of a finance department’s day to recalculate employee counts and commission payouts and these will become a labor cost unless there is justification for processing the true-up. Payroll providers will have a minimum threshold of true-up eligibility of 25-30% employee growth since the first payroll run.
Claw-back Optionality - To deter sales representatives from submitting all of their opportunities for true-up review a payroll provider will state that if an employer is found to have lost employees in a true-up that the sales representative who submitted for the review will have their commissions subtracted from.
Payroll Sales Rep Activity, Quotas, and Commissions
Goal: this document will outline the expectations a Check Partner should have of their payroll sales team from Beta to 6 - 12 months of GA. The reason for this timeframe is this is when your sales team are trained, have had a couple of initial conversations with payroll prospects, and before there is enough historical references for your team to forecast activity expectations.
Output: Sales Performance and Compensation Plan - This document will serve as a guideline for sales reps to understand their performance metrics, quota expectations, and potential earnings through commissions, fostering a motivated sales force aligned with company goals during the critical early stages of the payroll product's go-to-market strategy.
Activity
We are going to discuss this into 3 types of sales motions Check Partners find fit into their current GTM workstreams, then cover the baseline activity all sale motions go through, and finally review what, if any, adjustment considerations for each type of sales motion.
3 Sales Motions
All Products Inbound - These sales reps products all directly compliment each other and are easily cross-sold. Their activity consists of presenting on first-meetings / demos that are set for them through marketing and product-led initiatives.
All Products Inbound sales leads are mostly either window shopping or have nearly made their decision to move forward based on the marketing content and need to check a few last boxes. The sales rep needs to be able to quickly context switch between these two personas and effectively follow up with all first-meetings that don’t close they host.
Multi-Product Account Management - A sales motion a number of Check Partners have selected to use to sell payroll is including payroll as another product their Account Managers upsell their customer base with.
These Account Managers often have a working relationship with their book of customers and can easily schedule first meetings with their base. However, Check finds these sales representatives take longer to ramp as payroll has a high level of edge cases a sales rep must be able to discuss and knowing all of those edge cases on top of their other products can be challenging.
Payroll Only Current Customer Upsell - Check Partners that do have a suite of different products their platform offers find a blend of All Products Inbound and Multi-Product Account Management is the most effective model; or the hub-and-spoke model.
This model is built with 1 - 2 sales representatives sharing a round-robin style first-meeting booking system as well as partnering with their core product Sales teammates and Marketing on the outbound content to the customer base.
Baseline Activity Expectations
Understanding the baseline expectations of a payroll sales representative's daily activity is vital for aligning performance goals and optimizing time management. It ensures consistent, high-quality customer interactions while enabling effective performance assessment and targeted improvement efforts.
- Preparation Research: Spend 5 - 10 minutes for each scheduled meeting a sales rep has for the week to research the prospect so they can be prepared to speak directly to assumed pain points for prospect personas of customers that are window shoppers as well as be prepared to respond to customers who are mostly sold but need a couple of quick “can-it-do” questions.
- First Meeting / Demo: Each of these meetings should take 30 minutes and be focused on direct pain point extraction questions, quickly covering “can-it-do”, and showcasing how your payroll platform will positively impact the payroll prospect’s business.
- NOTE: It is necessary for your payroll sales representatives to assume the sale and end these meetings by asking if they have any objections to moving to your payroll platform and to schedule their implementation call.
- Follow Up: If the prospect has questions the sales representative was not able to address on the First Meeting/Demo, they will need to have fast and effective follow up with the payroll prospect. An effective sales representative should plan on needing to follow up with a prospect 3 times before the second meeting is locked in, with each time being a 5 minute activity. Therefore, a sales rep should expect to spend 15 minutes per week on follow up for each first-meeting they host.
- NOTE: Extracting the follow up time requirements, you can quickly calculate how impactful having a strong First Meeting/Demo is to maximizing your sales velocity.
Activity Considerations for each Sales Motion
Adapting sales activity expectations based on different sales motions is essential because each motion, whether All Products, Multi-Product AM, or Payroll Only, requires distinct approaches and time investments. Tailoring expectations ensures sales teams focus on the appropriate activities that resonate with the specific motion, leading to more relevant customer engagements and higher chances of successful conversions.
All Products Inbound | Multi-Product AM | Payroll Only | |
Preparation Research | Higher volume, needs to be able to quickly tie payroll into different customer personas. | Knows customers more intimately and should be able to tailor value to individual business cases. | Receives opp handoff info from other products teams and/or review customer databases. |
First Meeting / Demo | Target 6 - 8 meetings per week | Target 3 - 4 meetings per week | Target 6 - 8 meetings per week |
Follow Up | Must respond quickly and enter into an automated campaign to book implementation call. | Will have more follow up action items due to not being able to deep dive on payroll education. Should plan on having a follow up meeting after each demo. | If rep receives a lead from another product team, keep all parties updated on progress. |
Quota
Creating a sales quota for a new product requires a balance between setting ambitious goals and being realistic about the challenges of launching something new. Regular assessment and adaptation are key to ensuring the quotas remain aligned with the evolving market landscape.
For the timeframe this document covers, Beta to first 12 months of GA, Check recommends sales goals instead of quotas to hold sales representatives accountable to. An important note is that the majority of Check’s Partners find the legacy payroll sale funnel still applies to their sales motion, even when selling to current customers. This sales funnel is a 10 - 33 - 90 rule; 10% of your outreach will book a demo/first meeting, 33% of those prospects will say yes after 1 - 3 meetings, and 90% of that demographic will process their first payroll within 45 days of starting their implementation.
Therefore, work with your finance and sales leadership teams to create your sales goals and work backwards to create your sales goals.
Commissions
In the dynamic realm of sales, a finely tuned payroll sales representative commission structure stands as the nexus between fiscal prudence and unbridled motivation. Striking the delicate balance between minimizing costs of commissions and igniting sales representatives' fervor is not just a challenge; it's a strategic imperative. This section will cover sales commission payout amounts, thresholds for amplified payouts, clawbacks, and true-ups.
It is Check’s recommendation to launch your payroll product with a single commission payout percentage of first year’s estimated revenue. After 12 months of operating in GA you may consider adding features to your commission payouts.
NOTE: There are unique California rules for commission based pay. Prior to determining the rules regarding the use of commissions as a form of compensation in the state of California, it is important to understand how the state of California defines commissions. Please request more information from Check if you have sales representatives based in California.
Payouts
The critical considerations for how to payout the sales commissions are:
- Commissions are only paid out on the last payroll run of the month after the first payroll run month.
- Example: Acme Inc. processes their first payroll on February 6th and the payroll provider is on bi-weekly payroll so the sales rep will be paid their commissions on the last payroll run of March.
- Revenue amounts are calculated by multiplying the revenue of the first month of the first payroll run by 12.
- Acme Inc. ran in February with 10 employees at $10 monthly fee + $5 PEPM. The sales representative will be paid out on $720 of ARR.
- Future additional product upsell opportunities are calculated based only on PEPM.
- In April Acme Inc. adds ATS at $1.50 PEPM and the sales representative is paid out on $180 of ARR.
- Legacy payroll providers start their commission payouts between 9% - 11% of ARR.
Considering the structure of other products a payroll company is selling when adjusting their commission payouts is crucial to ensure equitable compensation. This approach prevents disproportionate incentives that could lead to neglecting certain offerings, promoting a balanced focus on the entire product portfolio and maximizing overall business growth.
All Products Inbound | Multi-Product AM | Payroll Only | |
Commission | Consider adding multipliers to selling full product suite opportunities. | Payroll can be a longer and more technical sales cycle. Ensure the payout for the time and effort put into payroll is competitive. | Check recommends a 80/20 commission split between payroll only and other product sales reps. |
Appendix
Please consult with Check before applying any of the commission adjustments.
Commission Amplifiers
Commission amplifiers are used to motivate sales representatives to push more products per sales opportunity as well as rewarding top performers. There are three primary forms amplifiers take:
- Unit Sales - SMB payroll sales opportunities take the same amount of administrative time from a sales representative of gathering the required information to hand off to implementation. In order to ensure sales representatives are treating all SMB sales opportunities equally a payroll provider will give a higher percentage of commission payout on ARR based on the volume of unit sales.
- Product Cross-selling - A fully built out Payroll/HR product stack includes ATS, New Hire Onboarding, HRIS, Benefit Admin, Timekeeping, Learning Management System, and many more platforms. These products have their own ARR associated with adding them to a sales opportunity but to motivate sales representatives to push more products a payroll provider can add higher percentage of commission payout based on the number of products that are cross-sold per sales opportunity.
- Revenue Targets - The most common commission amplifier is providing revenue milestones for your payroll sales representatives to hit that will elevate them into a higher percentage of commission payout. It is critical that you understand your payroll economics to properly map out revenue target amplifiers because misallocated buckets can cause your greatest sales representatives to become a liability instead of an asset.
Commission Clawbacks
A commission clawback is when a previously paid out sales opportunity ends their service agreement with a payroll provider within a defined clawback period. The reasoning of why payroll providers add clawback windows is to ensure the sales representatives are effectively selling their opportunities and/or keep their clients engaged so that if issues arise they can help address them before churn. Common clawback clauses are often reflected in the size of the sales opportunities with SMB requiring 30 - 60 day windows and mid-market and above requiring 90 days.
An example is if a sales representative was paid $100 in commissions in March for a deal that ran February 1st and has a 60 day clawback window policy. The employer ends their service with March 27th and so that sales representative will have $100 deducted (or clawed back) from their April commission check.
Commission True-ups
A sales "true-up" refers to a process in which a company reconciles or adjusts sales commissions or incentives that were initially estimated or paid based on provisional data. This often occurs when sales data or metrics are subject to changes, corrections, or updates after the initial commission payments have been made. The true-up process involves comparing the initial commission calculations with the updated or accurate sales figures, and then making necessary adjustments to ensure that sales representatives receive the appropriate amount of compensation based on their actual performance.
Employee count on seasonal businesses can fluctuate wildly and incentivizes sales representatives to submit higher employee count businesses during their peaks instead of when it is most advantageous to onboard the employer. This is why payroll providers will offer their sales representatives the opportunity to “true-up” an opportunity within a defined window and minimum threshold so that the sales representative still submits the opportunity when it is best for the employer and implementation teams.
There are three considerations when a sales representative submits for a true-up:
- Timeline - The main driver for offering true-ups is to adjust for seasonal employers and therefore most payroll providers limit the timeline a sales opportunity is eligible for a true-up to 6 months.
- Employee Growth - True-ups take time out of a finance department’s day to recalculate employee counts and commission payouts and these will become a labor cost unless there is justification for processing the true-up. Payroll providers will have a minimum threshold of true-up eligibility of 25-30% employee growth since the first payroll run.
Claw-back Optionality - To deter sales representatives from submitting all of their opportunities for true-up review a payroll provider will state that if an employer is found to have lost employees in a true-up that the sales representative who submitted for the review will have their commissions subtracted from.
Last updated on December 16, 2025